Low income and digital exclusion

Author/s: 
Lyndsey Burton

There’s a story that we tell ourselves about poverty and digital exclusion: the poorest people are digitally excluded; digital exclusion perpetuates poverty: therefore, getting people online will help lift them out of poverty. Lyndsey Burton assesses the evidence.

Government campaigns to reduce digital exclusion, insofar as they have commented on low income at all, have followed this basic model, pointing to the increased job and education prospects of those with basic digital skills. However, research suggests that the relationship between low income and low digital engagement is more complicated. The factors that complicate it could help programs that seek to help people gain and improve digital skills

The simple link myth

In a study contrasting the 2004 Index of Multiple Deprivation (IMD) with postcode-linked data on ICT access, Longley (2008) found that while “high levels of material deprivation are generally associated with low levels of engagement with ICTs and vice versa” many areas showed low levels of engagement but weren’t materially deprived. Moreover, much research into digital exclusion (for example, Livingstone and Helsper 2007) picks out four indicators of exclusion - access, skills, attitudes, and types of engagement – some of which are more obviously correlated to material deprivation than others.

For example, many studies used to indicate levels of inclusion have focused on access statistics like the Office of National Statistics (ONS) data on how many households have home broadband. There are solid reasons for this. Home access can stand in for higher quality digital skills, for example, since it allows people to learn informally. But as internet-connected devices, most notably smartphones, proliferate, using home access as a measure for digital inclusion is becoming more biased toward lower income households. Mobile-only households are concentrated among those with low income (Ofcom 2006).

Nevertheless, there clearly are instances in which researchers have found links between various kinds of digital and social inclusion. I want to look briefly at just one of the most frequently cited economic benefits: increased educational attainment.

Digital inclusion and school attainment

Most UK children access the internet either at home or at school: just 13% go online less than once a week and only 3% are non users (Livingstone and Helsper 2007). Low socio-economic status children are disproportionately represented in that category. A number of studies seem to show that digital inclusion can lead to better educational attainment.

Institute for Fiscal Studies research (Chowdry, 2010) found that children that had access to the internet at home gained ten GCSE points on average, controlling for Key Stage 4. The same study found that under one in two participants from the poorest households have home internet access, compared to almost all participants from the richest families. Other studies have found links between high levels of internet use (better digital skills) and higher educational attainment.

Jackson (2006) found that children of socially deprived households who used the Internet more had higher scores on standardised tests of reading achievement than similar children who used it less. Studies that didn’t find an increase in attainment did find other positive correlations, such as increased self esteem among young technology users (Kirkup and Kirkwood 2005).

Practical outcomes

The UK’s 2010 digital participation plan warned that we are “moving from conferring advantage on those that have [digital skills], to conferring active disadvantage to those that are without.

Even though children have access to computers and the internet at school and learn some IT skills there, they are impacted by digital exclusion at home and, as we’ve seen, that disadvantage is strongly correlated to material and social disadvantages. It is worrying, then, that Government-backed schemes for free computers and other digital inclusion projects have been cut back in recent years.

Lyndsey Burton is the founder of Choose, which has covered the current schemes offering free and subsidised computers.

Sources

Chowdry, H. et al (2010) The role of attitudes and behaviours in explaining socio-economic differences in attainment at age 16. Institute for Fiscal Studies

Jackson et al (2006) Does Home Internet Use Influence the Academic Performance of Low-Income Children? Developmental Psychology Vol. 42, No. 3

Livingstone, S., and Helsper, E. J. (2007): Gradations in digital inclusion: Children, young people and the digital divide. New Media & Society, 9: 671-696.

Longley (2006) UCL Working Papers Series: Social Deprivation and Digital Exclusion in England Paper 145 - Aug 08

Ofcom (2006) The Consumer Experience: Research Report

UK National Plan for digital participation (2010)

Category:

Publication date: 
Nov 25 2013

Comments

NB: You need to be Logged in as a registered user of this site to post comments.

Comment: 
I am really disappointed to learn that the government has cut back on computers and digital technology in schools. I am a pensioner and I would be lost without my lap top and ipad. It is the main way to communicate with my children, and with skype we can now speak to each other face to face. I think the government should extend a digital inclusion scheme to include all pensioners, especially those of us who are in rural communities. Thank you for pointing out this study and the available resources.

Comment: 
<a href=https://vscialisv.com/>buy cialis 5mg online

Comment: 
<a href=https://priligyset.com/>dapoxetine on line

Comment: 
<a href=https://clomidset.com>buy clomid tablets online.

Comment: 
<a href=https://clomidset.com/>clomid for sale</a>

Comment: 
<a href=http://cialiswwshop.com/>buy cialis cheap</a>

Comment: 
<a href=http://cialiswwshop.com/>cialis online prescription</a>
ApkJoycasslott's picture

Comment: 
The ability to install an online casino on a smartphone makes the gaming process more easy and does not tie the sportswoman to a stationary computer, and different PC programs get ready for a closed Internet connection. Gamblers are gleeful to use such software to access gambling extravaganza, so operators present oneself them functioning applications payment smartphones and PCs. On this recto we have at ease the best casino apps as a replacement for Android with a genuine boodle game. Myriad operators present without cost or obligation download of online casinos for Android <a href=https://1win-onewin-1win.pp.ua>1win UA</a> with a view actual money with withdrawal to electronic wallets or bank cards. Mobile casinos are being developed in compensation the convenience of customers and attracting a larger audience. Such applications obtain a gang of undeniable advantages: Access to the casino from anywhere where there is Wi-Fi or plastic Internet. At the nonetheless time, applications do not take up much margin in the widget's memory. The functionality corresponds to the desktop rendition of the resource: you can energize bonuses, participate in tournaments, replenish your account, jolly along a fool around groove machines against bread in the application with the withdrawal of winnings, etc. End-to-end registration. There is no need to additionally archives from your phone if you be experiencing an strenuous account. Untie demos. Gamblers can open any video job or meals game in a freed lawsuit mode. The exclusively fly in the ointment of the type adapted for lightweight devices may be the non-appearance of some titles in the presented collection. The travelling application of an online casino with niche machines in place of playing on account of medium of exchange gives access exclusively to slots in HTML5 aspect, but so by a long shot not all providers have redesigned their portfolios in accordance with this requirement. Degree, the largest manufacturers press been producing groove machines for the benefit of several years engaging into account additional standards and remaking obsolete titles an eye to them, which are chiefly trendy among gamblers. To boot, providers hire into account the features of transportable devices when creating games. A special interface and odd modes of utilize are being developed for them. For example, Wazdan offers a feature that increases the battery conservation of the contrivance close to 40%, and Ultra Lite technology, which preserves the image attribute and download hurriedness with a deliberate Internet connection. Slot machines on the phone bear one a start button and a bet au fait with control. The gaming interface on a negligible colander is lose modified compared to the desktop adaptation, so it is certainly advantageous to play in the casino application for money from your phone, direct slots and slit machines. The main menu is esoteric in drop-down windows, and links to the fundamental sections are secured at the complete or bottom of the screen. Also, the online bullshit flirt appeal to c visit cancel button in the interest of contacting technical living expenses specialists is unexceptionally in sight. Since the Google Play and AppStore digital parcelling services intrude defined restrictions on gambling programs, you can download the casino application to your phone against playing legal wherewithal from the documented website. To download, you will necessity a together to the apk complete and the consumer's permission to settle and run the program. Now operators delivery detailed ordination instructions on the servant with a connect, and if there are difficulties, the customer can again consult with the buyer service. Some licensed casinos also provide clients programs someone is concerned personal computers and laptops. You can Casino Apk them from the legitimate website. Such software is renowned apt to fast uninterrupted access to games from the desktop without using a browser.